Dr. Oz: Long Island Medium Theresa Caputo Speaks Out Against Critics NEXT PAGE ADVERTISEMENT Dr. Oz: Is Theresa Caputo a Fraud? Theresa Caputo from Long Island Medium came by Dr. Oz talk about being a medium. Dr. Oz said that some critics call her a fraud. What does she say to that? “I don’t say anything. I feel everyone’s entitled to their own opinion. I have a beautiful and amazing gift that helps people and I just don’t focus on the negative,” she said.